Nature often reveals her secrets only on a closer look. Nature is not always in your face, screaming for your attention. The test is to peel away the layers of the obvious.

Birders keep score by identifying species. Birders have devised a number of games (life lists, Christmas Bird Counts, Big Days, Big Sits) through which "winning" is determined by the number of species seen. Add a few unexpected birds (the rarities), and the victory is secure.

Yet there is a drama beneath the species level that waits to be told. Birds communicate their identity (species, gender) through song and plumage. The challenge in birding is to be able to decipher these markers and tap into the identity of the bird in question. Yet birds often differ in plumage and voice across a geographical range within the same species. These same identifiers or markers (plumage, voice) may reveal the geographical origins of a bird as well.

For example, the Katy Prairie (west of Houston, Texas) is the destination for a wide variety of diurnal raptors in winter. The most common hawk of this prairie is the Red-tailed Hawk, and to see 200-300 in a day afield is not out of the question. Yet Red-tails are notoriously variable, with an impressive variety of distinct geographical populations. There are eastern Red-tails, western Red-tails, Harlan’s Red-tails, Krider’s Red-tails, dark morphs, light morphs, and intermediate morphs. All converge in winter on the Katy Prairie, making these open grasslands perfect for studying Red-tailed Hawks in all of their permutations.

Granted, this is only one species. On the day’s tally, this gains you only one tick off of the list. Yet for those willing to invest in the closer look, the world of the Red-tailed Hawk will unfold on the Katy Prairie.

The Palm Warber is another example of a North American bird with identifiable geographical populations. The western Palm Warbler (palmarum) is a plain drab gray/green in the winter, accented with a blush of yellow near the tail. The western Palm breeds almost exclusively in Canada, spreading east to the Great Lakes. The eastern Palm (hypochrysea) is extensively yellow, developing a bright rufous crown and banana-yellow underparts during breeding. The eastern Palm breeds from the Great Lakes (where it intergrades with western birds) east to the Maritimes.

Both subspecies winter in the southern U.S. and the Caribbean, from east Texas to Florida and the Caribbean islands. As would be expected, the winter population mirrors the breeding in that western Palms predominate in Texas, with eastern birds generally wintering east toward Florida and the Caribbean. The closer look, however, reveals a more interesting pattern.

During winter the eastern Palm retains a distinctive yellow cast, and is therefore normally separable from the western palmarum. In other words, the two geographical populations may be distinguished in the field. In the same region mentioned above (the Katy Prairie) in the discussion about Red-tailed Hawks, the Palm Warbler is a regular winter resident. Palms are habitat specific, and are normally found only in huisache groves and adjacent brush. As would be expected, palmarum is the Palm Warbler normally seen in this region, yet for every four or five palmarum there is one hypochrysea. Here, at the western extent of the winter range, there are birds that represent the easternmost breeding population as well.

In the past few have looked closely at wintering Palm Warblers in Texas. The most recent Checklist of the Birds of Texas notes that the "status is unknown" for hypochrysea in Texas. Yet isn’t this ornithological black hole partially related to a species-centric perspective among birders? One Palm Warbler is as good as another when filling out the day’s checklist. Why take the closer look?

Wildlife viewing is rooted in a mesmeric curiosity about the natural world that surrounds us. Without taking that closer look, much of the drama that takes place in nature is transformed into a two-dimensional caricature. We are not interested in a Reader’s Digest version of the natural world. Palm Warblers from the Maritimes as well as the Yukon may winter shoulder to shoulder in the huisache thickets of the Texas Brazos River bottom. Now that would seem worthy of a closer look.

Fermata Home | Trip Du Jour Culture | Nature | History | Archives Subscribers Login | Subcribers Apply Lost Password?
	Fermata Inc. P.O. Box 5485 Austin, Texas 78763-5485 Office: (512) 472-0052 Fax: (512) 472-0057 E-mail: info@fermatainc.com	Fermata, Inc. PO Box 148 Hampton, NY 12837-0148 Office 802 287 4284 FAX 802 287 4285
Please report any problems with the site to webmaster@fermatainc.com Site design by Ghostwriters Communications All content ©1999 - 2003 Fermata Inc. Photos ©Ted Eubanks and Seth Davidson